Jump to content
Welcome! ×
Atomic Mass Games Forum

Raph

Members
  • Posts

    6
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Raph

  1. Hello! When does Han Solo (Scoundrel for Hire)'s pilot ability happen during an attack? The wording says "After you roll dice", which would mean it happens after step 2a "Roll attack dice", but before step 2b "Modify attack dice". However, the answer to this question implies that Han Solo's ability happens midway through step 2b, with the rest of the attacker's modifications: Does Han Solo's ability happen after step 2a? Or does it happen in the middle of step 2b, with the attackers modifications? If it happens in step 2b, does it have to happen first, or can it be done in any order, like the rest of the attacker's modifications? Thank you!
  2. Do effects that reduce defense dice but aren't generated by an enemy ship (such as Strain, Tractor, or Structural Damage) reduce defense dice when defending at Range 0?
  3. Hey guys, multiple questions about the hidden Illicit card granted by the Razor Crest title. For reference, that card reads: Question 4: Is this card chosen during list building or during setup? Must this card be the same during each round of a tournament, or can a new card be chosen each round?
  4. Hey guys, question about the hidden Illicit card granted by the Razor Crest title. For reference, that card reads: Question 3: Is this facedown card known to your opponent, or is this information hidden until the card is revealed?
  5. Hey guys, question about the hidden Illicit card granted by the Razor Crest title. For reference, that card reads: Question 1: Does this card allow you to place a card facedown that is a duplicate of a card you have equipped?
  6. (My preemptive apologies if this forum is not the correct place for Tournament Regulations questions. If there is somewhere else this should go, please let me know.) The rules for stalling/fortressing in the Tournament Regulations are as follows: However, this is not how stalling/fortressing has been consistently ruled at many events all the way up to the highest level for the past few years. For most judges, the "none have changed positions" clause has effectively been ignored in favor of judgement calls, though even this is by no means uniform. Some judges rule stalling/fortressing only per the above text as quoted, and some rule any instance of avoiding direct engagement as stalling/fortressing. As there is no "Judge Academy" for X-Wing that would provide consistency between judges, these "unwritten rules" and the "you know it when you see it" rulings around stalling/fortressing lead to confusion and inconsistency between events. What is legal in one event might not be legal in another event the following week, with no change in written rules anywhere, which is unfair to players. Can we get an official and specific set of rules for what stalling/fortressing in this game means, so that rulings do not vary wildly from judge to judge and event to event?
×
×
  • Create New...